Two banks can fight over the same commercial account on Monday and sit side by side at an industry forum on Tuesday, comparing notes on regulation, fraud and cybersecurity.
Nobody hands over a customer list. They compare maps.
But when companies consider putting competing customers in one room for a customer advisory board, you can watch the wince happen in real time. What if someone accidentally reveals a competitive advantage they’d rather keep to themselves? What if participants hold back, worried that saying too much could give a competitor an edge?
Those are fair concerns. But they assume that bringing competitors together means asking them to share what gives them a competitive edge. It doesn’t.
The Blind Spot
Your customers compete for the same buyers. They’re also navigating many of the same challenges, often in isolation.
The same regulatory changes. The same increasingly complex buying committees. The same pressure to do more with less. The same boardroom questions about AI that nobody has a clean answer to yet.
Each customer is holding one corner of the map. They have their own experiences, assumptions and interpretations, but none of them can see the whole territory. You can. You serve all of them, which puts you in the only seat where the patterns are visible.
That’s an advantage. It only pays off when you connect the dots.
Where the common ground actually lives
Rivals don’t compete on everything. They compete on how they respond to market conditions, serve their customers and differentiate themselves.
That leaves plenty of safe territory:
Shared business challenges. The pressures affecting everyone in the category, from hiring and margins to changing customer expectations.
Emerging priorities. What’s moving up the list for executives, what’s getting more attention, and how they’re thinking about what’s next.
Where the industry is heading. The longer-term shifts that will shape the next three to five years. Understanding those shifts doesn’t require anyone to reveal their competitive playbook.
The goal isn’t to get competitors talking about how they run their businesses. It’s to give them a window into how others are navigating the same challenges, making decisions and adapting to what’s changing.
How to keep the room competitor-safe
Good intentions aren’t enough. The conversation needs structure.
Set expectations before anyone walks in. Make the purpose, discussion boundaries and confidentiality expectations clear in the invitation. Participants should understand what can be shared outside the room and what stays in it.
Build the agenda around the market. Frame discussions around industry questions and shared business challenges. Pricing, named accounts, competitive strategies and confidential roadmaps are off the table.
Use a neutral facilitator. A neutral facilitator keeps the conversation focused on participants and the issues that matter to them, rather than the vendor’s agenda.
Be thoughtful about who sits at the table. Direct competitors can absolutely participate, but the mix, seniority and discussion topics matter. The objective is to create a room where everyone has something to contribute without feeling exposed.
The intelligence you can’t get alone
When customers talk to each other about the market, something different happens.
One executive raises a challenge. Another sees it differently. A third connects it to something happening in their own business. Assumptions get challenged, and connections emerge that never surface in an individual interview or survey.
The value isn’t hearing more customer opinions. It’s watching the corners of the map line up.
That’s what your roadmap, your messaging and your retention plans should be built on: how your customers’ markets are actually moving, straight from the people making the decisions, not how one customer described it in a survey.
The cost of staying out
Your customers collectively understand this market better than any one of them does. The question is whether you’re in the room when those pieces come together.
Skip it, and you’ll hear what you missed in a lost-deal note. By then, the map was drawn without you.